Lancaster at a glance

  • 1978Median year homes were built
  • 18%Homes built before 1940
  • 21%Homes that are rented
  • 15%Homes in 2 to 4 unit buildings
  • $277,600Median owner-occupied home value
  • 5%Commutes of 45+ minutes

Flood insurance: The Town of Lancaster takes part in the National Flood Insurance Program. Its current flood map took effect June 7, 2019.

Census figures: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020 to 2024 5-year estimates for Lancaster town, Erie County, New York.

What a Lancaster home's build year means for coverage

Lancaster's housing spans generations. Of its housing units, 17.6% were built in 1939 or earlier and 34.1% before 1960, yet the median year built is 1978, so about half the town's housing dates to 1978 or later. Owners in that pre-1960 third should note when the roof, electrical, plumbing and heating were last updated, because carriers ask about all four. Census data puts the median owner-occupied value at $277,600. Home insurance should cover what the house would cost to rebuild, not its market price, and older homes can cost more to rebuild than their sale price.

Renters make up 20.9% of Lancaster's occupied homes, and while 68.6% of housing units are single-family detached houses, 14.5% are in buildings with 2 to 4 units. If you rent, your landlord's policy does not cover your belongings or your liability; renters insurance does. If you own a building with 2 to 4 units and live somewhere else, you need landlord coverage, also called rental property insurance, rather than a standard owner-occupant policy. Owners who keep one unit as their own home and rent the rest should ask us about coverage designed for owner-occupied multi-family buildings.

Auto coverage for Lancaster's solo commuters

Lancaster runs on cars: 80.2% of all workers drive to work alone. Few of those trips run long, with just 4.8% of workers who do not work from home spending 45 minutes or more getting there one way. New York requires every auto policy to carry at least 25/50/10 liability, $50,000 of no-fault (PIP) coverage and uninsured motorist coverage. Completing a DMV-approved defensive driving course (PIRP) cuts the base rate of your liability and collision premiums by 10% for three years. We compare auto insurance across 45+ companies.

Hitting a deer is generally covered under comprehensive, not collision, while sliding into another car or a guardrail is generally a collision claim. Not sure your Lancaster policy carries both comprehensive and collision? Phone 716-885-8100, where a real person picks up. Clients also get the Willoughby Guarantee: an automatic re-shop of the policy at every renewal.

Winter roofs and Lancaster's 2019 flood map

Lake-effect snow accounts for more than half of the area's yearly snowfall, according to the National Weather Service in Buffalo, and it is very localized, with prevailing winds sending much more of it to areas south of Buffalo than to places north. A standard homeowners policy generally covers a collapse caused by the weight of snow or ice, burst pipes and leaks from ice dams. Wear and slow leaks are generally excluded.

None of that extends to flooding, because no homeowners or renters policy covers flood; that takes a separate policy through the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) or a private insurer. The Town of Lancaster (FEMA community 360249) participates in the NFIP. Lancaster has had a Flood Insurance Rate Map since December 1, 1981, and today's version is dated June 7, 2019. Because NFIP policies generally take 30 days to start, one bought after a storm shows up in the forecast is unlikely to be in force when it hits.

FAQ

Lancaster: common questions

Where do Lancaster homeowners get flood coverage?

Lancaster homeowners get flood coverage from a separate policy, because homeowners and renters policies do not cover flood. You can buy one through the National Flood Insurance Program or a private insurer. The Town of Lancaster (FEMA community 360249) participates in the NFIP, and its current flood map took effect June 7, 2019. NFIP policies generally take 30 days to start, so buy one before you need it.

What should I gather before insuring a pre-1960 Lancaster house?

Gather the dates of the last roof, electrical, plumbing and heating updates on your house, because carriers ask about those on older homes. Homes built before 1960 make up 34.1% of Lancaster's housing units, and 17.6% were built in 1939 or earlier. Insure the house for what it costs to rebuild, not its market price, because an older home can cost more to rebuild than it would sell for.

How do you insure a 2-to-4-unit building in Lancaster?

About 14.5% of Lancaster's housing units are in buildings with 2 to 4 units, and their owners fall into two camps. If you rent out the units and live elsewhere, you need landlord (rental property) coverage rather than a standard owner-occupant policy. If you live in one unit, ask us about a policy written for owner-occupied multi-family homes. Your landlord policy does not cover your tenants' belongings or liability; renters insurance does.

Trusted locally

Lancaster's neighbors trust Willoughby.

5.060+ Google reviews

Let’s look at your Lancaster coverage.

Tell us what you want to protect, and we can help you compare options across 45+ companies.