Amherst at a glance

  • 1971Median year homes were built
  • 8%Homes built before 1940
  • 30%Homes that are rented
  • 15%Homes in 2 to 4 unit buildings
  • $311,600Median owner-occupied home value
  • 5%Commutes of 45+ minutes

Flood insurance: The Town of Amherst takes part in the National Flood Insurance Program. Its current flood map took effect June 7, 2019. As a FEMA Community Rating System Class 8 community, flood policies get a 10% discount in the high-risk flood zone and 5% outside it.

Census figures: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020 to 2024 5-year estimates for Amherst town, Erie County, New York.

Homes, renters and small multi-unit buildings in Amherst

The median Amherst home was built in 1971, 30.9% of local housing went up before 1960, and 8.2% dates to 1939 or earlier. Put a median owner-occupied value of $311,600 next to that 1971 build year, and you can see why sale price and rebuild cost can part ways here. Insure the home for what it would cost to rebuild, because an older home can cost more to rebuild than it would sell for. Owners of older houses should expect carriers to ask when the roof, electrical, plumbing and heating were last updated; bring those years along and we can answer up front when we shop your home insurance.

About 3 in 10 occupied homes in Amherst are rented (30.1%), and 15% of housing units sit in buildings with 2 to 4 units. If you rent, your landlord's policy does not cover your belongings or your liability; renters insurance does. If you own one of those small multi-unit buildings, the right policy depends on where you live. Owners who rent out the units and live elsewhere need rental property coverage. Living in one unit while renting out the others is a different setup, so ask us about owner-occupied multi-family coverage for that.

Amherst drivers and the solo commute

Long commutes are rare in Amherst. Only 4.7% of workers who do not work from home spend 45 minutes or more getting to work, while 73.8% of all workers drive there alone. For nearly 3 in 4 Amherst workers, then, the car is how the workday starts, and New York requires auto liability of at least 25/50/10, $50,000 of no-fault (PIP) coverage and uninsured motorist coverage. Our first pass at your auto insurance compares 45+ companies, and under the Willoughby Guarantee that comparison runs again automatically at every renewal.

For Amherst's solo commuters, two lines on an auto policy are worth knowing apart: comprehensive, not collision, generally covers hitting a deer, and collision generally covers sliding into another car or a guardrail. If you are one of the 73.8% of Amherst workers who drive to work alone, ask us about a DMV-approved defensive driving course (PIRP), which cuts the base rate of liability and collision premiums by 10% for three years. Questions about the course or your coverage go to a real person at 716-885-8100.

Snow north of Buffalo and Amherst's flood discount

Lake effect produces over half of the area's yearly snowfall, per the National Weather Service in Buffalo, and prevailing winds carry much more of it to places south of the city than to places north of it. Amherst is north of Buffalo, so it sits on the side that gets less. Standard homeowners policies generally cover a collapse caused by the weight of snow or ice, burst pipes and ice-dam leaks, while wear and slow leaks are generally excluded.

The Town of Amherst (FEMA community ID 360226) takes part in the National Flood Insurance Program. Amherst has had a flood insurance rate map since December 18, 1984; the one in effect today is dated June 7, 2019. The town is Class 8 in FEMA's Community Rating System, which gives NFIP policies a 10% premium discount inside the high-risk flood zone (Special Flood Hazard Area) and 5% outside it. No homeowners or renters policy covers flood. It takes a separate policy through the NFIP or a private insurer, and because an NFIP policy generally waits 30 days before it begins, raise it with us well ahead of time.

FAQ

Amherst: common questions

Does Amherst get a discount on flood insurance?

Yes, on NFIP policies. The Town of Amherst is Class 8 in FEMA's Community Rating System, which gives National Flood Insurance Program policies a 10% premium discount inside the high-risk flood zone and 5% outside it. Flood is never part of a homeowners or renters policy, so it takes a separate policy through the NFIP or a private insurer, and NFIP coverage generally takes 30 days to start.

If I rent in Amherst, am I covered by the property owner's policy?

No. A landlord's policy does not cover a tenant's belongings or liability; renters insurance does. That applies to the roughly 3 in 10 Amherst households who rent, including tenants in the town's 2-to-4-unit buildings, which hold 15% of local housing units. Willoughby Insurance compares renters coverage across 45+ companies, and a real person answers at 716-885-8100.

How much coverage should I carry on my Amherst home?

Enough to rebuild it, which is not the same as its market price. Owner-occupied homes in Amherst have a median value of $311,600, but the median home here was built in 1971, and an older home can cost more to rebuild than its sale price. Carriers ask about roof, electrical, plumbing and heating updates on older homes, so have those dates ready when we shop your policy.

Trusted locally

Amherst's neighbors trust Willoughby.

5.060+ Google reviews

Let’s look at your Amherst coverage.

Tell us what you want to protect, and we can help you compare options across 45+ companies.