Serving Grand Island, New York
Insurance in Grand Island.
Island homes, boats, and autos, all in one place. As a local, independent agency, we shop your coverage across 45+ companies to find the right fit for Grand Island families, then keep your price down at every renewal.
Why Grand Island chooses Willoughby
A local agent in your corner.
We have been a Western New York business since 1952, just down the road in Buffalo.When you call, you reach a real person who knows the area and works for you, not for one insurance company.
45+ companies, compared
We shop Grand Island coverage across many top carriers so you are never stuck with one price.
The Willoughby Guarantee
Every renewal, we re-shop your policy to keep your Grand Island rate as low as it can be.
Service that stays
Changes and renewals handled by people who pick up the phone, and a local agent in your corner when you have a claim.
Coverage
Protection for Grand Island families.
From your home and cars to the boat and the lake house. We write it all.
Auto Insurance
Protect yourself on every Buffalo road.
Learn moreHome Insurance
Cover the place that matters most.
Learn moreRenters Insurance
Affordable protection for your apartment and your stuff.
Learn moreCondo Insurance
Coverage that fills the gaps your association leaves.
Learn moreUmbrella Insurance
An extra layer of liability when you need it most.
Learn moreHome & Auto Bundle
Combine policies and save, with one simple bill.
Learn moreGet your Grand Island quote today.
Free, no pressure, and shopped across 45+ companies.
Areas we serve nearby