Family-owned since 1952 Three generations in Buffalo Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) Independent: 45+ carriers Now appointed with The Hartford Licensed across New York State

Who we cover

You run on your expertise, your reputation, and the trust your clients place in your advice. Whether you keep the books, close the deals, write the code, argue the cases, or run the campaigns, a single mistake or a quiet data breach can cost you more than a flooded basement ever would. Willoughby has insured Western New York businesses since 1952, and we know the difference between a downtown Buffalo law office, a real estate team in Amherst, and a software shop in the Larkin District. We build commercial coverage around how your office really operates, not a one-size template.

Risks we see in WNY

  • A client claims your advice or work caused them a financial loss
  • A data breach exposes client records and triggers notification costs
  • A slip-and-fall by a client or visitor at your office
  • Theft, fire, or a burst pipe damaging computers, files, and equipment
  • A laptop or phone with client data is lost or stolen offsite
  • A staff dispute leading to a wrongful termination or harassment claim
  • Downtime from a ransomware attack or extended power loss

Coverage that fits

What offices & professional services typically need.

A starting point, not a checklist. We tailor the right mix to your actual operation.

Professional Liability (Errors & Omissions)

Covers claims that your professional advice, service, or work caused a client a financial loss, including the cost to defend you.

General Liability

Handles third-party bodily injury and property damage claims, like a client who slips in your lobby or is hurt at a meeting.

Cyber Liability & Data Breach

Responds to hacking, ransomware, and exposed client data, covering notification, recovery, and liability costs.

Business Owners Policy (BOP)

Bundles property and liability into one policy to protect your office space, computers, furniture, and records.

Workers' Compensation

Required in New York once you have employees, covering medical bills and lost wages for work-related injuries.

Employment Practices Liability (EPLI)

Defends against claims from staff over wrongful termination, discrimination, or harassment.

The Willoughby difference

One agent. Many markets. Your side of the table.

Willoughby is an independent, family-owned agency that has served Western New York since 1952, so we shop your coverage across many carriers including The Hartford, Hanover, and Security Mutual to fit your office and your budget. You work with a local agent who answers the phone, not a call center three time zones away.

Request a consultation

Now placing business with

The HartfordThe HanoverSecurity MutualGeicoNational GeneralEmployersProgressive Commercial

and more through our agency network.