You have a start date, a customer waiting and an email asking for a certificate of insurance. Before forwarding the email with “please send a COI,” take a few minutes to assemble the complete request.
A certificate request is easier to review when your agent can see who is asking, what work you will perform and the exact insurance requirements. A useful request also makes any mismatch visible before a crew arrives at the job.
This checklist is for New York contractors preparing that conversation. It does not determine whether a contract is acceptable or whether your insurance satisfies every requirement.
First, understand what the certificate does
A certificate summarizes insurance information. It does not independently create new coverage or expand the policy. The ACORD 25 certificate currently listed among New York DFS-approved forms explains that the certificate does not change coverage or confer rights on its holder. If a customer requests a change, the agent needs to determine whether the existing policy supports it or whether an authorized policy change is needed. NY DFS: Approved ACORD 25, December 2025 edition.
That distinction matters when a request includes more than a name and address. Do not assume that putting requested wording on a certificate makes it part of the policy.
Send one complete request
Create a single folder or message containing the following information. Use your agency’s established secure method for sending policy documents.
| Item | What to include |
|---|---|
| Your business | Exact legal business name and the best person to contact |
| The job | Address, project description and anticipated work dates |
| The requester | Legal entity name, mailing address and contact details |
| Requirements | The full insurance exhibit, contract section or written request |
| Requested documents | Certificate, endorsements and any specified government forms |
| Deadline | When the documents are needed and who will review them |
| Operations | What you will actually do, including new or seasonal activities |
Avoid sending only a screenshot of one sentence if the requirements span several pages. If the customer has a sample certificate, include it as a reference while asking the agent to review the actual requirements. Keep the original files so everyone is working from the same version.
Flag requests that need a closer look
Tell your agent if the requirements mention additional insured status, waiver of subrogation, primary and noncontributory coverage, completed operations or particular cancellation-notice wording. You do not need to interpret those provisions yourself. You do need to provide the complete language and ask how it compares with your policy.
Ask two separate questions: “Does my insurance provide what is being requested?” and “What documents can demonstrate it?” If the answer is uncertain, resolve the question with the agent and requester before relying on the paperwork. Insurance review and legal review of your contract serve different purposes.
Keep a record of the final requirements, the documents supplied and any written clarification. That file is useful when the project changes or someone asks for a replacement copy.
Government permits may require different proof
For New York state or municipal permits, licenses and contracts, an ordinary ACORD certificate is not acceptable proof of workers’ compensation coverage under Workers’ Compensation Law section 57. The Workers’ Compensation Board lists specific documents, including C-105.2, NYSIF’s U-26.3 and applicable self-insurance forms. NYS Workers’ Compensation Board: Government requirements.
The same WCB guidance explains that CE-200 is for showing a government agency that the business is exempt when eligible; it is not proof of exemption to another business or its insurer. Ask the permit office which documentation it requires and have your agent review the insurance portion. Do not assume one document answers every question about a business’s coverage.
For background, see Willoughby’s workers’ compensation coverage page. Eligibility and requirements depend on the actual business, so describe the ownership, workforce and work accurately.
Review again when the job changes
An estimate can evolve into a different project. Tell your agent when the work, location, subcontractors, vehicles or other operations change, and ask whether that change affects the coverage discussion or documents. Do not reuse an old certificate as a shortcut without checking that it is appropriate for the new request.
For a practical example, imagine a landscaping business that receives a new request for snow-removal work. The right next step is to explain the proposed work to the agent, send the requirements and ask for review. The fact that the business already has a policy and certificate does not answer the new question.
Choose the right next step
Already insured through Willoughby? Use the Service Center to start a certificate request, and have the checklist ready. Ask about timing for your particular request; this article does not promise same-day issuance or approval.
Looking for contractor coverage? Review our contractors and trades page and request a business insurance consultation. Bring the job requirements so the conversation begins with the work you actually need to insure.
General educational information, not legal advice. Coverage is governed by the policy and endorsements. Submitting a request does not bind, amend or confirm insurance coverage.
